In an age where algorithms write sonnets and deepfakes blur reality, it’s easy to think human creativity is becoming obsolete. AI can generate content, design logos, even write music, faster, usually cheaper, and often impressively well. So, where does that leave us, the human creators?
As digital and onsite SEO specialists, we have a vested interest in this topic, which is highly relevant to us and our clients. This is why we have taken an in-depth look into some of the many reasons why authentic, human-written content still outperforms that created by AI.
People Crave Human Connection
Whilst AI can attempt to mimic tone, style, even emotion, it can’t replicate the lived experience.
Most of the time, readers are able to tell when a piece of content comes from a real place, informed by personal insights, struggles, or humour. That human fingerprint resonates.
From sharing a vulnerable story, an honest opinion or a fresh perspective, these all spark connections. And connection leads to trust; something no algorithm can manufacture.
The Internet Is Drowning in Generic Content
Let’s be honest: much of what AI produces sounds the same. It’s cold, impersonal, low-quality and… forgettable. Churned out by bots and algorithms, AI-written content often means sacrificing quality and personality, flooding the internet with recycled articles, blogs and web copy.
Authentic content stands out precisely because it doesn’t sound like everything else. The quirks, writing style, voice, character and specific points of view; these are just some of the advantages that human-written materials have over those generated with AI tools.
In a sea of sameness, authenticity is your lifeboat.
Lack of Creativity and Emotion
Because AI systems rely on existing information to generate content, it means that they are often simply reusing, rewording and recycling stuff that is already out there. When it comes to choosing engaging subjects, topics and themes, AI can be extremely repetitive and have the same soulless, robotic style.
For content and blogs, for example, most topics will have black and white areas that AI tools are usually able to cover sufficiently. However, it’s those critical grey areas where the lines are blurred that tend to be more subjective, and these can be lost on artificial intelligence, which isn’t able to mimic the human approach with the same nuance.
However, when a person produces content, their emotional intelligence and creativity bleed into their writing, creating work that is more engaging, truthful and enjoyable to read.
Audiences Are Getting Smarter
People are now better able to identify AI-generated content. There are subtle hints that usually give it away, whether it’s being a little too polished, lacking that punchy insight or missing personal anecdotes which help bring ideas to life. Consumers want realness, not reheated blog-speak.
The most successful creators today aren’t the ones gaming the system to churn out cheap, regurgitated and characterless pages of meaningless words; they’re the ones showing up with honest, genuine and exciting content that people enjoy reading and want to engage with.
Algorithms Reward Authenticity
Ironically, even the algorithms are starting to favour authenticity with many platforms like Instagram, TikTok and YouTube rewarding unique, raw and unfiltered content to the top. Why? Because it performs better. People engage more with content that feels real, and that tells the platforms to show it to more people.
Search engines are also evolving. Google’s helpful content updates now reward original, experience-based writing over keyword-stuffed fluff to prioritise them in search results over that generated by AI. This means that even the machines are learning to value what only humans can offer.
Trust Is the Ultimate Currency
Whether you’re a creator, a brand, or a business, trust is what keeps people coming back. If your audience believes you’re real, they’ll stick with you, even if your content isn’t perfectly edited or your blog posts don’t go viral. If they are continuously exposed to uninspiring, spammy and boring copy, then this can create feelings of disconnection and that maybe you don’t align or are not compatible with their needs, feelings and beliefs.
Everyone understands that in the busy world, shortcuts are part of getting things done, but there comes a point where these time-saving tricks cause more harm than good. By taking the time and effort to create real, honest and well-thought-out human content, you have a much better chance of ensuring your audience stays engaged.
Remember, AI can create impressions. Only you can build relationships.
Final Thoughts
Let’s be clear, AI is an incredible tool, and when used wisely, it can amplify your voice, streamline your process, and help you get more done. But tools don’t replace truth, and they certainly don’t replace you.
So instead of blindly relying on AI to write everything for you, use it as a tool to help draft ideas, brainstorm headlines, outline posts and fill in some blanks now and then. But remember that the final product should always be infused fully with your own values, your voice and identity, as that’s what people want and what they will remember.
Ready to Put Authentic Content Marketing at the Centre of Your Marketing Strategy?
You’re making a great choice! Get in touch with our content marketing experts today!
